Friday, February 20, 2009

What do you do when no one assumes leadership?

Steve Wright, an Academy Award-winning American comedian, actor and writer said, “There's a fine line between fishing and just standing on the shore like an idiot.” ***********************************************************************************


Nature abhors vacuum. “It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles, or where the
doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood, who strives valiantly; who errs and comes short again and again; because there is not effort without error and shortcomings; but who does actually strive to do the deed; who knows the great enthusiasm, the great devotion, who spends himself in a worthy cause, who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement and who at the worst, if he fails, at least he fails while daring greatly. So that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who know neither victory nor defeat.” ~ Theodore Roosevelt quotes (American 26th US President (1901-09).
******************************************************************************************


What do you do when no one assumes leadership? What is the fine line between ambition and indifference? Shouldn’t we do what is right rather than what is legal?

Comments (28)

  1. Todd L. <span class=Greges

    Todd L. Greges

    National Director - Professional Services ...................... Lean Six Sigma Certified

    Take charge myself.... then determine who should truly own and lead the effort. Once done, gain concensus and drive the case for ownership by said individual or group.
    Always do what is right

    Posted 20 days ago |

  2. This is typical of poor governance situations - where there is no accountability. It could be a very frustrating environment for someone who is result oriented. So, that person has one of the following choices to make:
    1. Run away from it
    2. Become one of them
    3. Change the situation

    The third option option can be implemented in various ways. As long as the goal is noble, means to the end does not matter - whether it is to lead from the front or influence the group(or the de facto leader).
    Distinction between ambition and indifference is very easy to spot. Ambition has positive vibes while indifference has negative. It is clearly reflected in the character of the individual. As someone once said: A person's character is revealed by what (s)he does when nobody is watching.

    One should never forget that true leadership is commanded and NOT given. You lead because people follow. You owe it to yourselves and to the followers to always do the right thing.

    Posted 19 days ago |

  3. Mark Frey

    Mark Frey

    Executive Director at Community Connections of Brockton

    Step up or step off...

    Posted 19 days ago |

  4. <span class=Kathakali Chatterjee

    Kathakali Chatterjee

    Manager:Spencer's Retail (Speciality Vertical)

    Absolutely.

    Lead, or follow, or get out.

    Posted 19 days ago |

  5. Joyce <span class=

    Joyce Feustel

    at Joyce Feustel - Professional Speaker

    Benjamin, you bring up a matter that, in my opinion, is at the core of why so many membership-driven clubs are struggling today, with many already having "closed up shop." In his book Bowling Alone author Robert Putnam traces historical patterns of the decline in civic engagement since the 1960s. I highly recommend this book to anyone who hasn't already taken it in. Less willingness to serve in a leadership capacity is one of those aspects of civic engagement tracked by Putnam in his book.

    I have been in leadership roles in volunteer organizations and clubs since my 20s, and being that I just turned 60, I have a few decades of experience around this matter of a void in leadership. What I believe is incumbent upon the existing leaders of any group is to help the members see that leadership can be a joy and something worthy of devoting one's time and energy to - as opposed to a drudgery that someone has to do. In addition, current leaders need to constantly keep their antenna up to notice the next generation of leaders in that group, be willing to hand over the reins at the appropriate time and available (if needed) to mentor those new leaders.

    What I have noticed in Toastmasters clubs is that the clubs that struggle with membership challenges and low energy have leaders who stay too long in their position, perhaps not trusting that next generation to capably lead the group.

    Finally, I believe that if a group essentially has one leader who is fast approaching burn out and has tried and tried to solicit others to take on leadership roles, well it just might be time for that group to dissolve.

    Posted 19 days ago |

  6. Paula <span class=

    Paula Brookshire

    Pre-Sales Consultant and Business Development

    All great answers, but Sandeep voices my thinking exactly. I've always done what's right for my company, customer and team mates, usually in that order. But doing what has always made me successful failed me in my last position. I was forced out.

    I've talked to a few people I use to work with, who were on other teams. These people were some of the best I worked with, true leaders. They were forced out also. They were as puzzled as I was.

    So I've had lots of time to figure out what happened.
    When a company's leadership is siloed with no accountability to business outside their silo, you have big trouble. Now all that matters is doing the right thing for your manager, forget anything else. It may seem doing what's right for your manager would have the same results as doing what's right for the company, but that isn't always true.

    I mention my experience to make you aware of this difference. As more companies cut their resources, there will be more emphasis on making a profit. I'm afraid, ethics or doing the right thing will take a back seat.

    Posted 19 days ago |

  7. L. <span class=

    L. marie mcallister

    Potential Solar Magnate

    This is an another extreme question Benjamin. My first thought is nothing but a group of people is no one takes leadership. Then I rethink the ambiguity of your questions and what little I know of your personality.

    There is a huge line between ambition and indifference, almost opposites. Ambition is wanting something so much you can taste it and indifference is not even knowing what it "might" taste like or that IT even has a taste.

    Doing what is right, or what is legal. Loaded question my new friend. If what you THINK is right although illegal, then your choice is how much you believe in the importance of being right. Can your ego let the thought of being right go at the cost of being legal?

    Posted 19 days ago |

  8. Stacey Aldred

    Brother/Elder/Pastor Chinese Word of Life Church Boston

    You'd have to provide a case and determine it case by case because each case has unique variables.

    Natural born leaders will step up for sure but wise Christian servants of the Lord will consider the variables and take the matter to God and see what to do and not be so foolish as to just jump in and take control.

    Many verses and cases in the Bible address this issue. The wise will dig them out and the foolish won't.

    So present the actual case facts and then discuss it, rather than an abstract general "what if "case.

    Posted 18 days ago |

  9. Shay <span class=Villere

    Shay Villere

    Consultant & Entrepreneur

    Seen it happen. Normally there is enough organization to where there is someone to answer questions. That is all management typically does. In good companies those situations are worked out ahead of time. If not, you may want to consider jumping ship. I have quit jobs for problems less than that. I don't tolerate impractical companies. No one should.

    Posted 18 days ago |

  10. Steven <span class=

    Steven Eberly

    Principal at E-Z Enterprises, PR and advertising

    There's always a leader...even if it's the first guy to shrug his shoulders and sigh. Unbridled ambition can also lead a person to jump into a leadership role they're not prepared to handle, and really, there's no such thing as indifference. Better to ask why there's a lack of leadership in a given situation, and then work as a group to define the leader's role, and finally, seek the best person to fill it.

    Legal vs. right...as for me, I only have one rulebook and one judge, others have theirs. When the two cross, mine has yet to let me down.

    Posted 18 days ago |

  11. David Edwards

    David Edwards

    Independent Construction Professional

    “There's a fine line between fishing and just standing on the shore like an idiot.”

    Not true. One has a purpose and the other doesn't. There is a gulf between them.

    "Shouldn’t we do what is right rather than what is legal?"

    Absolutely, but in a competitive market, legal and financial constraints are the only playing field levellers we have got. And on a global scale, even these don't work. We see human and environmental exploitation rampant. Humans and the environment are competitive issues and until a way out of that is found, there will be no right.

    And don't rely on our nanny-state politicians. They only pretend that they know what they're doing.

    Posted 18 days ago |

  12. Michael Hartwell

    Michael Hartwell

    Program Manager at ANXeBusiness

    figure out why no one is leading.

    Posted 18 days ago |

  13. Monica Leibacher, BS.Ed, LMT, Aromatherapist

    Monica Leibacher, BS.Ed, LMT, Aromatherapist

    Owner of Rosewood Holistic Health LLC and specializing in craniosacral therapy and aromatherapy

    I have to agree that if there is no leader and I deem the cause worthy that it is my responsiblity to be the leader. But..What about when the 'leader' is not leading (I am not speaking in terms of my opinion of the leadership provided, just simply the lack of leadership by the appointed leader)? I would tend to think that the step up and take the lead approach creates apathy in that person. What do you think?

    Posted 17 days ago |

  14. C. Benjamin Anyacho, MBA*2500+LION Leaders &Thinkers

    C. Benjamin Anyacho, MBA*2500+LION Leaders &Thinkers you

    Co-host at Austin Arise! Radio & TV

    You'll are fun! Fabulous answers! David, I think "gulf" is better than "fine line." People should lead, follow or get out of the way!

    Posted 17 days ago |

  15. Julie Poland

    Julie Poland

    Certified Business Coach

    There are "inside" ways of looking at this and "outside" ways:

    From the Inside (looking at me)
    * Is this important enough to me for me to take a leadership role?

    * Is this important enough to my company/my community that I should step forward? (stewardship concept)

    * Am I doing this because I want to help results happen, or just because I want to be seen leading? (ambition vs. leadership)

    From the outside (looking at the organization)
    * Are people waiting for permission rather than taking action? That's potentially a clue that the culture slays people when they make mistakes. You can't have peak performance (or cultivate leadership) until you drive out fear.

    * Is there a direction that people have agreed upon and that more than one person is fired up about? When you don't have buy-in you have a limited pool of potential leaders.

    * Have one or two committed people created one or two overwhelming roles that they've now burnt out on? Unless they look at HOW the work gets done they create an all-or-nothing environment that discourages leaders from stepping up.

    There's way more to this, but enough for now.

    Posted 15 days ago |

  16. Ms Himadri Rajb.

    Ms Himadri Rajb.

    Jr.Supdt.i(Admn), IITGuwahati [OpenNetworker.com]

    “There's a fine line between fishing and just standing on the shore like an idiot.” **

    Right now this is my situation in my venture. But I decided not to return back with zero and will try, still trying till the end of my last
    breath.Want to know the root cause and searching like mad and of course hope is there to got/achieved my quest to leadership a little bit.

    And striving for at moon place if not at lease get a place with stars.

    If we not tried then how do I/We know what is right or legal? At least we should try for which is going to happened.

    Patience, persistence, to be implemented .
    and overcome any negative hurdle and stay focus on Positive way.

    Many to be pondering............Writing from my own experience.


    thanks C.B.A

    Posted 14 days ago |

  17. Amal Desai

    Head: Secured Lending Performance Analysis

    In most circumstances there is generally more than one individual who is willing to "step up to the plate" & lead the way. The key to the teams success will lie within determining what skill is required for the leader of this unit, & then assessing who fits the profile, both internally & externally.

    Getting in & driving the appropriate behaviour in identifying the leader, will yield a sustainable/desireable outcome over a longer period.

    Whats the greater injustice, having no leader at all, or a the leader with the wrong attributes for the required team & task at hand?

    Posted 14 days ago |

  18. Lory Mitchell

    Lory Mitchell

    at Lockheed Martin Aeronautics

    Reevaluate the goal. Make sure it properly aligns with the business strategy. If no one steps up there is a misalignment somewhere.

    Posted 12 days ago |

  19. Vasilij Savin

    Vasilij Savin

    Student at Uppsala University

    I am a bit disturbed by Sandeep's claim, that when goal is noble, ends justify means. Since most goals can be presented as noble, it leads to disasters. History knows many examples of that.

    Right or legal - not a fair question, since both are relative (country/culture/religion). Better stick with what is right within legal in your environment.

    Posted 11 days ago |

  20. We cant go higher then our faith.If you feel you are ready then step upfrond and take charge, if not step down and let the one who is take the lead.

    Many people today have stept in where they dont belong they are wearing bigger shoes thats why we are in this mess around the world!


  21. Dr Kadiyali Srivatsa

    Dr Kadiyali Srivatsa

    MD at Medifix Limited

    Hi Benjamin, Why do you think no one will assume leadership?

    They certainly will its matter of time. Most leaders are shy people, they do not want to stand-up and shout aloud and make a fool of themselves. To be a good leader, they need the opportunity and gain some experience to lead. I am sure some one will soon stand-up and start shouting load. I am only scared of waking up barking mad dog to lead us.

    This law of nature, it happens all the time in our the world, more powerful than "Darwin’s Theory of Evolution"

    “When the world gets out of control (present), a mad man will be born to lead; the good ones will be helpless as this mad man leads to destroy the universe".

    It is like waking up a sleeping lion, please watch him, a force that is difficult to curtail. He will be ruthless, strong and passionate about what he wants to achieve. These leaders will shun away their family, worldly possessions and simply believe in what they do, and “LEAD US”, you and I will have no choice but to follow this leader like a lame duck.

    I am here in your group because I am not keen to take the back seat and watch the drama unfold.

    Posted 9 days ago |

  22. Phil Williams (LION)

    Phil Williams (LION)

    Financial Freedom Advisory Services

    Depends... without vision we perish... IS THERE A VISION and if so ... what are the accountabilities.
    Assuming a vision with stated accountablilites ... then simply volunteer ... then recruit fellow volunteers whose talents and skill sets best fit the needs as articulated throuh the vision statement

    Where there no vision ... it is a social event and ENJOY especially is you are getting paid to participate.

    This sums up where so many organizations are today
    Thanks for posing this question

    Posted 8 days ago |

  23. ISMAEL AYLES, CPA

    ISMAEL AYLES, CPA

    ACCOUNTING, ASSURANCE, AND TAX RELATED SERVICES

    Think first where you stand and determine the extent of your power or authority.

    Know your strength and weaknesses, and don't hesitate to seek for help if you think that you cannot competently do the tasks at hand.

    Our society has so many legal impediments and limitations, and it is stupid to set them aside otherwise you will land in jail.

    Posted 7 days ago |

  24. Filipe Farelo

    Filipe Farelo

    Director at Consulgal

    Hi there Benjamim and all.
    My answer to the question, What do you do when no one assumes leadership? is simple... LEAD 360º You can lead from every part of the organisation. It's in you to make the difference.

    To the question Legal vs. Right...Always Legal!

    Posted 7 days ago |

  25. Gerald A. "Doc" Thomas

    Gerald A. "Doc" Thomas

    Aerospace Science Instructor--Dixie High School

    "Also I heard the voice of the Lord, saying, Whom shall I send, and who will go for us? Then said I, Here am I; send me."--Isaiah 6:8. What you're asking is inconsistent with the verse above. Not everyone is prepared for leadership and the one's that are equipped are afraid to take the lead because of what others may say. Some are downright ashamed of the Gospel because of teasing, hatred, and not being a good student of the Bible. Paul stated: "For I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ: for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth; to the Jew first, and also to the Greek."--Romans 1:16.

    Being a teacher of Leadership, I train all my student to be prepared to take charge. Many are afraid, many are embarrassed, many are overly aggressive which takes us to every corner of the spectrum. The problem lies in the amount of time we have to make the decision and how important or dangerous the decision is. When people come together there's normally a formal leader that has the leadership position and is thus empowered to make decisions then there's the informal leader, the leader that the group trusts and expects to take over when time is crucial. However, if the two leaders are killed or unable to physically perform, what happens then? We must prepare other to be leaders.

    In my 26+ years of Air Force service, we build leaders. It's our job to train each person under us to be prepared to take over when I and others move on. We must empower others to take leadership positions or pray that God will make them "willing to be made willing." We must be conformed to the image of God and be always ready to give an answer. We must face the world everyday and be girded up for the battle.

    If we're looking at this from a godly perspective, we have our instructions in the Bible. Leaders don't run from problems they run to the problem and plough through it. "When Goliath started forward, David ran toward him. He put a rock in his sling and swung the sling around by its straps. When he let go of one strap, the rock flew out and hit Goliath on the forehead. It cracked his skull, and he fell facedown on the ground. David defeated Goliath with a sling and a rock. He killed him without even using a sword. David ran over and pulled out Goliath's sword. Then he used it to cut off Goliath's head. When the Philistines saw what had happened to their hero, they started running away."--1 Samuel 17:48-51.

    If we are looking at it from a worldly perspective, we must run to Throne of Grace and ask the Lord to forgive us. We must keep the Word of God and hide it in our hearts that we will not sin against God. We must pray without ceasing thus, having His Word first and foremost on our minds. By doing so we will be ready to assume the lead from a godly perspective.

    Posted 6 days ago |

  26. Scott Saunders

    Scott Saunders

    Business Intermediary at Murphy Business and Financial

    Then you get the mess that we are in today. As a person once said, The only thing evil needs to triumph is for good men to do nothing.

    Self serving leaders will always emerge. They are ambitious, selfish, have large egos, often charismatic and eloquent. Hitler is one example of an obvious terrible, but effective leader. The German citizenry accepted his views thereby affirmed his leadership.

    Servant leaders are the opposite. Selfless, sacrificial, principled, and passionite about the mission and greater long term good of the organization. George Washington is a great example of this kind of leader. William Wallace and Jesus Christ were others.

    Apathy of course is inbetween. If we have learned anything from our current financial mess, it is immoral decisions sans any principled and accountable leadership can negatively affect many innocent moral people. That is the price of indifference.

    In terms of doing right versus doing what is legal, stay legal unless it violates God's higher law. If you want to avoid a conflict between the two, I reference back to my second sentence.

    Posted 4 days ago |

  27. Paul Bridle (paulbridle@paulbridle.com)

    Paul Bridle (paulbridle@paulbridle.com)

    Bridle Reasearch and Development Ltd

    First of all be thankful - because at least there is nobody doing it for the wrong reasons. Secondly, nurture the team as a group (don't lead it). A leader will emerge eventually and in the meantime you will have a team that works together.
    Paul
    www.paulbridle.com
    www.thoughtsonleadership.biz

    Posted 16 hours ago |

  28. David Edwards

    David Edwards

    Independent Construction Professional

    “There's a fine line between fishing and just standing on the shore like an idiot.” *****************************************************************************************
    Not true. One has a purpose and the other doesn't. There is a gulf between them.

    "Shouldn’t we do what is right rather than what is legal?"
    *****************************************************************
    Absolutely, but in a competitive market, legal and financial constraints are the only playing field levellers we have got. And on a global scale, even these don't work. We see human and environmental exploitation rampant. Humans and the environment are competitive issues and until a way out of that is found, there will be no right.

    And don't rely on our nanny-state politicians. They only pretend that they know what they're doing.

    Posted 15 hours ago


5 comments:

  1. There is a huge line between ambition and indifference, almost opposites. Ambition is wanting something so much you can taste it and indifference is not even knowing it has a taste.

    ReplyDelete
  2. When no one assumes leadership what you get is a group of people.

    ReplyDelete
  3. --------------------
    Depends... without vision we perish... IS THERE A VISION and if so ... what are the accountabilities.
    Assuming a vision with stated accountablilites ... then simply volunteer ... then recruit fellow volunteers whose talents and skill sets best fit the needs as articulated through the vision statement

    Where there no vision ... it is a social event and ENJOY especially is you are getting paid to participate.

    This sums up where so many organizations are today
    Thanks for posing this question

    Phil Williams

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have to agree that if there is no leader and I deem the cause worthy that it is my responsiblity to be the leader. But..What about when the 'leader' is not leading (I am not speaking in terms of my opinion of the leadership provided, just simply the lack of leadership by the appointed leader)? I would tend to think that the step up and take the lead approach creates apathy in that person. What do you think?

    ReplyDelete
  5. There's always a leader...even if it's the first guy to shrug his shoulders and sigh. Unbridled ambition can also lead a person to jump into a leadership role they're not prepared to handle, and really, there's no such thing as indifference. Better to ask why there's a lack of leadership in a given situation, and then work as a group to define the leader's role, and finally, seek the best person to fill it.

    Legal vs. right...as for me, I only have one rulebook and one judge, others have theirs. When the two cross, mine has yet to let me down.

    ReplyDelete